023 9238 1114

Out of hours 08080 333363
Thursday, 06 February 2020 10:08

Perverse incentives?

Rate this item
(0 votes)

The Crown Prosecution Service was aware in 2015 that its conviction rate 'levels of ambition' could have unintended consequences, the Gazette can reveal. The service is facing a judicial review brought by a coalition of women’s rights organisations who argue the service has become more risk averse in its policy on rape cases. 

Numbers of rape prosecutions and convictions have fallen drastically in recent years despite record levels of allegations. The Gazette revealed last year that the levels of ambition - for rape, domestic violence and hate crime - were in operation at the CPS between 2016 and 2018 and were enforced by the service’s inspectorate, HMCPSI.  For rape, the ambition was for at least 60% of charges to end in conviction. During the period the measure was in force, the percentage of charged cases ending in conviction rose but actual numbers of convictions fell, raising fears prosecutors were weeding out weaker cases. A CPS spokesperson told the Gazette last year that the levels of ambition had been dropped over fears they might act as a 'perverse incentive'. The CPS has since denied the levels of ambition were used as targets at all, insisting they were simply performance indicators.

Siobhan Blake, CPS national lead for rape and serious sexual offences, told the Gazette: 'It is not the case we believed they were creating perverse incentives .'However a 2015 report of a consultation with chief crown prosecutors and area business managers, released by the CPS following the Gazette’s Freedom of Information Act request, made it clear that the levels of ambition were expected to drive up conviction rates. The report stated: 'The rape conviction rate has been falling for the past two years and now stands at 57.2% for the calendar year 2014. It is therefore appropriate to propose a level of ambition of 64% for 2015/16.

For full article https://www.lawgazette.co.uk/news/cps-knew-rape-ambition-could-have-perverse-consequences/5102974.article?utm_source=gazette_newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Pre-charge+bail+review+%7c+Beckwith+judgment+published+%7c+Aviation%27s+dodgy+dealings_02%2f05%2f2020

Read 24 times
More in this category: « Prison Crisis Legal limbo »